10
10
Containers have changed how we build and deploy applications. They make it easier to package software and run it anywhere. But managing containers at scale requires orchestration tools. That’s where services like Amazon Elastic Container Service (ECS) and Amazon Elastic Kubernetes Service (EKS) come in.
If you’re new to these services and want to understand their fundamentals, check out Part 1 of this blog, where we break down the basics of ECS vs. EKS.
Quick Comparison: AWS ECS vs EKS
Both ECS and EKS help automate the deployment, scaling, and management of containers. But they have key differences.
- AWS ECS is a fully managed container orchestration service that is deeply integrated with AWS services, offering simplicity, cost efficiency, and Fargate support for serverless container execution.
- AWS EKS is a managed Kubernetes service that provides multi-cloud portability, advanced orchestration, and customization capabilities but comes with a steeper learning curve.
To better understand the AWS ECS vs EKS comparison, let’s take a look at a comparative table.
Thus, both ECS and EKS are powerful container orchestration solutions on AWS, each offering unique advantages. While ECS provides a simpler, AWS-native framework, EKS offers greater flexibility and portability with Kubernetes. The right choice depends on your application needs and operational preferences.
When to choose Amazon ECS?
Amazon ECS is a great choice for a fully managed, deeply integrated container orchestration service within AWS. ECS pricing is also more cost-effective, with no additional management fees and flexible cost structures based on resource usage. It is designed to handle diverse workloads efficiently, offering seamless scalability, automation, and security.
Specific scenarios where ECS excels
- Modernizing legacy applications
If you have legacy applications that need better scalability and portability, ECS makes containerization straightforward. It allows you to migrate existing applications with minimal refactoring, ensuring they run efficiently in a modern cloud environment.
- Building cloud-native microservices
ECS is ideal for organizations developing microservices-based architectures. With deep AWS integrations (like Amazon RDS and DynamoDB), ECS helps teams build and manage scalable, decoupled applications while automating service discovery and networking.
- Need automated CI/CD pipelines
For teams focusing on continuous integration and deployment, AWS ECS vs EKS comes down to automation and ease of use. ECS integrates seamlessly with AWS CodePipeline, enabling automated application builds, testing, and deployments. This allows teams to roll out updates with zero downtime, ensuring faster and more reliable releases.
- Running batch processing and High-Performance Computing (HPC) workloads
For applications that require high computing power, such as scientific simulations, AI model training, or large-scale data processing, running ECS on EC2 allows you to choose compute-optimized or GPU-enabled instances to match workload needs. With AWS ECS, you can perform auto-scaling of instances based on demand, ensuring optimal performance without over-provisioning resources.
- Deploying serverless and event-driven applications
When comparing AWS ECS vs EKS for serverless and event-driven workloads, ECS with AWS Fargate stands out. It eliminates the need for infrastructure management, making it an excellent option for running event-driven applications, serverless workloads, and applications with unpredictable scaling needs.
- Consistent deployment across hybrid and on-premises environments
With AWS ECS Anywhere, you can deploy applications both on AWS and on-premises infrastructure. This ensures consistency across development, testing, staging, and production environments - reducing configuration drift and deployment risks.
- Automated scaling for cost optimization
ECS supports auto-scaling policies, dynamically adjusting the number of tasks based on demand. This ensures optimal performance during peak loads while minimizing costs during low-usage periods.
- Centralized logging and security
ECS integrates with Amazon CloudWatch for monitoring logs and setting up alerts. This makes it easier to track application health, detect anomalies, and proactively address issues before they impact users.
Whether you're modernizing applications, running microservices, or seeking cloud cost optimization, ECS provides the flexibility and efficiency to meet your cloud goals.
When to use Amazon EKS
AWS EKS is the right choice if you need Kubernetes for container orchestration, hybrid or multi-cloud flexibility, or advanced networking controls. It works well for large microservices, machine learning, and applications that require persistent storage or GPU power. However, EKS pricing includes an additional cluster management fee, making it a costlier option compared to ECS, especially for smaller workloads.
Specific scenarios where EKS excels
- Kubernetes-based workloads
EKS is the go-to choice for businesses that want to run applications in a Kubernetes-native environment. It allows organizations to take advantage of Kubernetes’ extensive ecosystem, including Helm charts, custom controllers, and service meshes like AWS App Mesh and Istio.
(Learn how to optimize costs in EKS with our blog on Kubernetes Cluster Management.)
- Hybrid and multi-cloud deployments
For businesses managing workloads across on-premises and multiple cloud environments, the choice between AWS ECS vs. EKS becomes clearer - AWS EKS is the better fit, as it simplifies hybrid and multi-cloud deployments. With EKS Anywhere, you can run Kubernetes clusters on your own infrastructure while maintaining the flexibility to move workloads between AWS and other cloud providers. Additionally, EKS integrates with AWS Cost Management tools, helping businesses track cloud spend across multiple environments and optimize resource allocation.
- Custom networking and advanced security
EKS offers granular control over networking through features like custom VPC configurations, security groups, and Kubernetes Network Policies. It also integrates with third-party security tools, making it ideal for businesses that require highly customized security configurations.
- Stateful applications and persistent storage
Unlike ECS, which is optimized for stateless services, EKS is well-suited for stateful applications such as databases and data-intensive workloads. It integrates seamlessly with Amazon EBS, EFS, and FSx, providing reliable persistent storage.
- Machine learning and high-performance computing
Both tools support high-performance computing, however, while comparing AWS ECS vs EKS, the latter supports GPU-powered workloads better, making it a strong choice for AI/ML applications. It works with deep learning frameworks like TensorFlow and PyTorch, and integrates with SageMaker for efficient training and inference tasks.
- Self-managed Kubernetes add-ons and customization
EKS allows teams to install custom Kubernetes add-ons, such as Prometheus for monitoring, Fluentd for logging, or custom admission controllers. ECS, in contrast, has a more rigid, AWS-managed structure with fewer customization options.
- Scalable web applications
AWS EKS enables developing highly available web applications over multiple availability zones with the capability of automatically scaling in and out. In addition to its performance, reliability, scale and availability, the EKS platform also helps in load distribution of these applications by integrating with AWS security and networking services.
Both EKS and ECS provide automated scaling, AWS integrations, and cost optimization through Spot Instances. They ensure high availability, security, and seamless deployments.
However, Amazon EKS is the better choice if you need advanced networking, cross-cloud portability, or Kubernetes-specific tools.
AWS ECS vs EKS: Decision Framework
Selecting the right container orchestration service depends on your workload requirements, operational complexity, and cloud strategy. Here is a quick checklist to determine the best fit for your workloads:
You can use this flowchart as a high-level guide to selecting the right container management service. While it doesn’t cover every specific edge case, these key factors can help determine whether ECS or EKS is the better fit for your workloads.
AWS ECS vs. EKS vs. Fargate
Comparing ECS, EKS, and Fargate isn’t exactly fair because Fargate isn’t a separate service - it's a compute option for running containers in ECS and EKS. While ECS and EKS help you manage and orchestrate containers, Fargate takes care of the underlying infrastructure, so you don’t have to worry about managing servers. With proper right-sizing and task scheduling, you can further optimize costs, ensuring you only pay for the resources you actually need.
When to Use AWS Fargate?
Fargate is ideal when you want to focus on running containers without managing the underlying infrastructure. It automatically provisions and scales compute resources based on demand, making it a great option for teams that prefer a serverless approach.
Use Fargate when:
- Your workload already runs on serverless technologies or you plan to transition in the future.
- Streamlining infrastructure management is a priority for productivity and cost efficiency.
- You only need container-level permissions and minimal customizations.
- Whether you use Docker or Kubernetes doesn’t significantly impact your decision.
- Running your own components is essential, but managing EC2 instances is not.
- You are comfortable using only AWS VPC networking mode.
- You want a mix of Fargate and EC2 tasks within the same cluster for flexibility.
- Paying only for compute time, without managing EC2 instances, aligns with your cost strategy.
AWS ECS vs EKS: How to make the right choice?
Amazon ECS and EKS both help you run containerized applications, but they serve different purposes. ECS is the easier, more AWS-native choice, perfect for teams that want a fully managed service with minimal setup. It’s great for businesses modernizing legacy apps, building microservices, or running batch workloads without worrying about Kubernetes complexities.
EKS, on the other hand, is built for companies that need the flexibility of Kubernetes. It’s ideal for hybrid or multi-cloud deployments, advanced networking, and high-performance applications like machine learning. While ECS keeps things simple, EKS offers more control and customization, making it better suited for enterprises with complex workloads.
When it comes to cost, ECS pricing is usually the more affordable option, especially for AWS-focused businesses. AWS EKS comes with extra overhead since EKS pricing includes a cluster management fee, but it makes sense if your team already knows Kubernetes and needs its advanced features.
Ultimately, the right choice depends on your infrastructure, how much control you need, and your team's expertise. If you want a straightforward, AWS-managed experience, go with ECS. If you need flexibility and scalability, EKS is the way to go.
Simplify container orchestration and minimize costs with CloudKeeper
Choosing between AWS ECS vs EKS is just one part of building an efficient containerized environment - optimizing workloads, managing infrastructure, and controlling costs are crucial too. CloudKeeper helps businesses streamline container management by providing expert guidance on architectural improvements, orchestration strategies, and cost efficiency.
With a team of certified AWS architects and cloud specialists, CloudKeeper ensures that your applications are built for scalability and performance while keeping operational complexity in check. From re-architecting workloads to implementing best practices in container orchestration, our approach helps organizations make the most of their cloud investments.
Book a free consultation with one of our experts and learn how you can make the most of your container environment while reducing your cloud costs.
Frequently Asked Questions(FAQs)
1. How does AWS ECS work?
AWS Elastic Container Service (ECS) is a fully managed container orchestration service that allows you to run, scale, and manage containers. It supports both EC2 instances and AWS Fargate, giving you flexibility in resource management and scaling.
2. How to deploy a service in AWS ECS?
Deploying a service in ECS involves creating a task definition, configuring a cluster, and setting up a service to manage container instances. ECS handles scaling, load balancing, and updates, ensuring smooth application deployment.
3. What is an AWS ECS cluster?
An ECS cluster is a logical grouping of tasks and services running on either Amazon EC2 instances or AWS Fargate. It helps manage resource allocation, networking, and scaling for containerized applications.
4. What are ECS tasks, and how do they work?
ECS tasks are individual instances of a containerized application. A task definition specifies the Docker image, CPU/memory allocation, networking, and IAM permissions required to run a container within ECS.
5. What is AWS Fargate in ECS?
AWS Fargate allows running containers without managing EC2 instances. It automatically provisions compute resources and scales as needed, making it ideal for serverless and event-driven applications.
6. When should you use ECS instead of EKS?
ECS is ideal when you need simple container orchestration with deep AWS integration, minimal operational overhead, and cost efficiency. It is a great choice for microservices, batch processing, and auto-scaling applications.
7. Why use EC2 in AWS ECS and EKS?
Using EC2 instances in ECS and EKS provides more control over networking, security, and cost optimization. EC2 allows for custom AMIs (Amazon Machine Images), reserved instance pricing, and better handling of workloads with specific performance requirements.
8. What is Kubernetes?
Kubernetes is an open-source container orchestration platform that automates scaling, deployment, and management of containerized applications. It enables multi-cloud and hybrid cloud deployments with advanced networking and security features.
9. How does AWS EKS work?
Amazon EKS is a fully managed Kubernetes service that simplifies running Kubernetes workloads on AWS. AWS handles the Kubernetes control plane, while you manage worker nodes and workloads. It integrates with AWS services for networking, security, and scaling.
10. What is an AWS EKS cluster?
An EKS cluster consists of a managed Kubernetes control plane and worker nodes running on EC2 or AWS Fargate. It provides high availability, scalability, and automation for Kubernetes workloads.
11. What is EKS Anywhere?
EKS Anywhere extends EKS to on-premises and hybrid cloud environments, allowing businesses to manage Kubernetes clusters outside AWS. It provides a consistent Kubernetes experience across cloud and on-prem infrastructure.
12. Why choose EKS instead of ECS?
EKS is better when you need multi-cloud flexibility, advanced networking, and Kubernetes-specific features like Helm charts and custom controllers. It is ideal for enterprises already invested in Kubernetes ecosystems.
13. Why is EKS more expensive than ECS?
EKS pricing has additional costs, including a $0.10 per hour per cluster control plane fee, higher operational complexity, and the need for specialized Kubernetes expertise. ECS pricing, in contrast, has no control plane cost and is easier to manage within AWS.
